Comparisons
Invoice factoring versus invoice financing
Factoring sells the invoice and your customer pays the factor. Financing borrows against it and nobody finds out. Below $85,000 a month, factoring is cheaper.
The short version. Factoring is a sale, so the factor owns the invoice, your customer is notified, and the factor collects. Financing is a loan, so you keep the invoice, nobody is notified, and you still do the collecting. Financing prices lower on paper. Factoring wins below about $85,000 of monthly invoice volume, and it wins any time you would rather not run a collections desk.
These two get used interchangeably in conversation and they are legally different transactions. Invoice factoring is a true sale of a receivable. The factor buys it, records it as an asset, and pursues your customer for payment. Invoice financing is a secured loan with the receivable as collateral. You still own the invoice and you still owe the money whether or not the customer pays.
The same $250,000 of invoices, priced both ways
Assume $250,000 of invoices to creditworthy commercial customers who pay on day 45, and an 85 percent advance rate under either structure, so $212,500 arrives up front. Factoring prices at 3 percent for the first 30 days plus 1 percent per additional 10 days. Financing prices at 18 percent on the drawn balance plus a servicing fee of 0.5 percent of face per month.
| Invoice factoring | Invoice financing | |
|---|---|---|
| Legal nature | True sale of the receivable | Loan secured by the receivable |
| Who owns the invoice | The factor | You |
| Cash up front | $212,500 | $212,500 |
| Cost at 45 days | $11,250 | $6,591 |
| Cost as a percent of the advance | 5.3 percent | 3.1 percent |
| Rough annualized cost | About 43 percent | About 25 percent |
| Customer notified | Yes, notice of assignment | No |
| Who chases payment | The factor | You |
| Monthly minimum | Usually none | Commonly $1,500 to $3,000 |
| Books required | Basic AR aging | Clean ledger, often a field audit |
| Time to set up | 3 to 10 days | 2 to 4 weeks |
| Typical term commitment | 12 months with an early termination fee | 12 months with an early termination fee |
On this single transaction, financing costs $6,591 against factoring's $11,250. That is a real 42 percent saving and it is why financing looks like the obvious answer on a spreadsheet. It stops being obvious the moment you look at volume, books, and who has to make the collection calls.
The break even, stated plainly
Most invoice financing facilities carry a monthly minimum, commonly $1,500 to $3,000, that you pay whether or not you use the line. Factoring generally has no minimum, because the factor earns on each invoice it buys. That single structural difference produces a clean break even.
At a $2,500 monthly minimum and factoring at 3 percent of face, the two cost the same when 3 percent of your monthly invoice volume equals $2,500. That lands at about $85,000 of invoices funded per month. Below roughly $85,000 a month, factoring is cheaper because you are paying the financing facility's minimum rather than its usage. Above it, financing pulls ahead and the gap widens with volume.
Confirm your own version of that number, because minimums vary and so does factoring pricing. Ask a financing lender for the minimum in dollars, ask a factor for the all in discount including any wire, audit, and processing fees, and divide. It takes ten minutes and it is the only part of this comparison that is genuinely arithmetic.
Who each one is actually for
- Factoring is for you if notification is normal in your industry, if your books are not audit ready, if your volume is under about $85,000 a month, or if chasing payment is genuinely costing you time you do not have. Freight carriers, staffing agencies, and government subcontractors factor as a matter of routine and no customer blinks.
- Financing is for you if a notice of assignment would damage a customer relationship, if you have a real accounting system and clean AR aging, if your monthly volume clears $85,000, and if you already collect reliably. An agency billing a venture backed client and a manufacturer with one large account both belong here.
- Factoring is the better tool if you have a genuine collection problem. You are not just buying money, you are outsourcing a function. A factor that calls your customers on day 32 is worth the extra points.
- Neither works on progress billed, disputed, pre billed, or pay when paid invoices. Both structures need a completed, undisputed, verifiable receivable. If the work is not finished, look at purchase order financing instead.
The three clauses to read before you sign either one
- Concentration limits. Both structures cap how much of your funded book one customer can represent, commonly 20 to 30 percent. If one account is 60 percent of your revenue, you will be funded on far less than you expect. See why concentration limits exist.
- Minimum term and early termination. Twelve month commitments are standard in both, with an early termination fee that is often the remaining minimums for the full term. Leaving in month three can cost you nine months of minimums.
- Lien position. Both file a UCC on your receivables and both want first position. If you already have an advance or a bank line with a blanket lien, someone has to subordinate before either facility funds. Find out what is already filed against you using a UCC search before you apply.
One more thing worth saying plainly. Both of these products are underwritten primarily on your customer, not on you. That makes them among the most accessible working capital tools available to a business with weak owner credit and strong commercial accounts, and it is why they routinely beat an advance for anyone who invoices. Compare that path directly in advance versus factoring before you sign a daily debit you did not need.
What we do with this
Exp Capital Solutions is a broker, not a lender and not a factor. We do not buy invoices and we do not set discount rates. What we do is read your AR aging and your monthly funded volume, run your own break even against the facility minimum, and tell you which of the two your numbers actually support. When factoring is right we say so, and when financing is right we say that instead, including the cases where a business is better off collecting faster and borrowing nothing. Then we put the offers side by side with the advance rate, the all in discount, the minimum, the term, and the recourse language in one place.